Ruschmeyer's Montauk: The Hamptons' Hottest Hotel? (You NEED to See This!)
Ruschmeyer's Montauk: Did the Hamptons Hotness Live Up to the Hype? (Spoiler Alert: It's Complicated, Baby!)
Okay, so I’ve just gotten back from a whirlwind trip to Montauk, and naturally, I HAD to check out Ruschmeyer's. They call it "The Hamptons’ Hottest Hotel?" – a bold claim, right? And as someone who's seen their fair share of "hottest" anything (and usually found them…meh), I’m here to give you the real deal. Buckle up, because this review is going to be a chaotic, honest, and hopefully, hilarious ride. I'm going to go deep, y'all. Like, really deep. And yes, this is a complete breakdown, so grab a snack and settle in. You've been warned!
First Impressions: The Vibe Check
Okay, so the vibe? Ruschmeyer's definitely leans into the "cool, hip summer camp for adults" aesthetic. Think rustic cabins, colorful picnic tables scattered around, hammocks swaying in the breeze, and a general air of casual chic. It’s definitely Instagrammable. I walked in, and immediately thought, "Wow, this is…a lot of wood." But in a good way? Maybe? It definitely has charm. But it's not immediately obvious how much it costs to stay there.
Accessibility: A Few Stumbling Blocks
Now, I’m not someone who needs extensive accessibility, but I always notice things. And honestly, Ruschmeyer’s could be a bit better here. They do have facilities for disabled guests, which is a good start. The elevator is a godsend, especially if you're in a higher floor room – because those stairs, though charming, can feel a bit never-ending. I didn't see detailed information on which rooms are wheelchair accessible and if the hotel offers accessible bathrooms. The paths to the dining area and pool seem manageable, but take it with a grain of salt. I recommend reaching out to the hotel directly if you have specific accessibility needs. The exterior corridor wasn't too wide, might be tricky.
The Room: My Tiny Cabin in Paradise (Kinda)
My room? Ah, the room. Available in all rooms: Air conditioning was a must-have in the July heat. Definitely appreciated. They provide Alarm clock, Bathrobes, Blackout curtains (THANK YOU!), Coffee/tea maker, Complimentary tea, Daily housekeeping, Desk, Extra long bed, Free bottled water, Hair dryer, In-room safe box, Internet access – wireless, Ironing facilities, Laptop workspace, Linens, Mini bar, Mirror, Non-smoking, On-demand movies, Private bathroom, Reading light, Refrigerator, Satellite/cable channels, Seating area, Shower, Slippers, Smoke detector, Socket near the bed, Sofa, Soundproofing, Telephone, Toiletries, Towels, Umbrella, Wake-up service, and Wi-Fi [free]. Everything was functional. Now, my room wasn’t huge, like, not at all, and no, not a lot of bells and whistles. I had an Additional toilet and Separate shower/bathtub, which was nice though. It’s definitely leaning towards the 'rustic' end of the spectrum. The Window that opens was a HUGE plus – fresh air is important. One thing: I couldn’t figure out how to close the window completely…which, with the howling wind off the ocean, was a bit problematic. The Interconnecting room(s) available might be great for families. The High floor, the one I stayed, was actually pretty nice.
Okay let’s be honest here. My room felt a little… basic. I had the kind of “rustic charm” that means a shower that’s a bit underpowered and a slightly wonky door. But hey, you aren’t coming to Montauk to spend all your time in a room. It did the job.
Internet: Wi-Fi Wanderings and a LAN Labyrinth
Free Wi-Fi in all rooms! – Praise be! Because let’s face it, we’re all glued to our phones. The Wi-Fi was (mostly) reliable, which is more than I can say for some hotels. They also provide Internet access – LAN, which… okay, I’m not sure why you’d need a LAN in 2024, but hey, it’s there, and the Internet services were standard.
Things to Do: More Than Just Chilling (Unless That’s Your Thing)
This is where Ruschmeyer's absolutely shines. It's all about that "laid-back luxury" lifestyle.
- Swimming pool [outdoor]: The pool is gorgeous. Seriously, a total highlight. It's stunning, with a Pool with view of the ocean.
- Fitness center: I popped in for a quick workout. It's small but well-equipped.
- Sauna, Spa/sauna, Steamroom: They have a spa! It was a little bit pricey. And the Foot bath was a nice touch after walking along the beach.
- Massage: Yup. They offer them. Definitely on the pricier side. After my massage, I just went and laid in a hammock for an hour.
- Bicycle parking: I didn’t cycle, but it's there.
- Things to Relax: Body scrub, Body wrap - Yup, you can indulge.
Safety and Cleanliness: Feeling Secure?
Let's be real, health safety is on everyone's minds these days. Here's what I noticed: The hotel has CCTV in common areas and CCTV outside property. Basic. They implemented Anti-viral cleaning products and Daily disinfection in common areas. They offered Hand sanitizer stations. Their staff appeared to be following safety protocols. They offer Room sanitization opt-out available. They used Professional-grade sanitizing services and Rooms sanitized between stays. I give them an "A" for effort. The place felt clean and safe.
Dining, Drinking, and Snacking: Fueling the Fun
Okay, this is another area where Ruschmeyer's really shines.
- Restaurants: There are several options. The main restaurant is a casual spot.
- Bar: Yup, a great bar. They do a mean cocktail!
- Poolside bar: Perfect for a margarita while you chill.
- Breakfast [buffet]: Standard breakfast buffet, with Asian breakfast and Western breakfast options.
- A la carte in restaurant, Coffee/tea in restaurant: You can order off a menu.
- Desserts in restaurant, Snack bar: I indulged in a few desserts.
- Room service [24-hour]: Always a bonus.
- Bottle of water: They provide this.
- Happy hour: Yes, please!
- Safe dining setup, Sanitized kitchen and tableware items: They clearly took pains to keep everything sanitary.
- Alternative meal arrangement, Vegetarian restaurant: They seemed very accommodating.
One day I went for the Breakfast takeaway service and ate by the pool!
Services and Conveniences: The Little Things
- Concierge: Helpful!
- Cash withdrawal, Currency exchange: Useful.
- Daily housekeeping: Much appreciated!
- Doorman, Elevator: A nice touch.
- Laundry service: Essential for a beach vacation.
- Luggage storage: Convenient.
- Safety deposit boxes: Security.
- Car park [free of charge], Valet parking: Parking is available.
- Airport transfer, Taxi service: Transportation options.
- Gift/souvenir shop, Convenience store: For those last-minute needs.
For the Kids: Family-Friendly Fun
- Babysitting service, Family/child friendly, Kids meal, Kids facilities: Ruschmeyer's definitely caters to families. I saw a few kids running around, and they looked like they were having a blast.
The Verdict: Worth the Hype? (Maybe… With a Few Caveats)
So, is Ruschmeyer's "hot?"
Yes, in many ways, it is. The location is incredible – you're steps from the beach and close to all the Montauk action. The vibe is fun and relaxed. The pool is AMAZING. The food is generally good, and the service is friendly.
However, it's not perfect. The rooms could be a bit more luxurious, and accessibility could be improved. It also definitely has a price tag to match the "Hamptons" label. This isn’t a cheap stay.
My Honest Rating: 7.5/10 (Could be an 8 if they address the accessibility and room niggles!)
But would I go back? Absolutely. Especially for a long weekend with friends or a low-key romantic getaway.
Here's the Deal:
- Book Now, But Consider These Factors: If you
Alright, buckle up buttercups, because this ain't your grandma's meticulously planned vacation itinerary. This is Montauk, baby. Ruschmeyer's? We're living in the messy, glorious present. Let's see if I can even remember what day it is…
Ruschmeyer's Montauk: A Slightly Disorganized Adventure (AKA My Sanity in Freefall)
Day 1: Arrival & The Beach, Baby. (Or, How I Accidentally Became a Sandcastle Architect)
- 1:00 PM: Touch down in Montauk. Okay, I knew I should have taken the Hampton Jitney. The taxi from the train station was like a slow-motion robbery, but hey, at least the driver had some stories. Apparently, he knows everyone.
- 1:30 PM: Check-in at Ruschmeyer's. Ah, the smell of salty air and vaguely expensive wood. Feeling a little…underwhelmed by the lack of a bellhop. (I'm trying to pretend I'm chill, okay?)
- 2:00 PM: Unpack. Okay, attempt to unpack. My suitcase exploded, basically. Swimsuit? Check. Sunscreen? Check. Emotional baggage? Also check.
- 2:30 PM: Beach time! Gotta find the beach. Should be easy, right? Wrong. Got slightly lost, wandering aimlessly, and nearly ended up in someone's backyard. Eventually, I found it. Finally.
- 3:00 PM - 6:00 PM: Beach life. Bliss. Sand. Sun. Waves. This is what paradise feels like. Except… I got roped into helping a kid build a sandcastle. This thing was epic, a real architectural masterpiece. I was way too involved in it, neglecting my tan. And then, the tide came. The kid’s face? Devastated. Mine? A mix of mortification and grudging admiration for the ocean's utter disregard for artistic merit. Lessons learned: Build on higher ground. And maybe stop getting so emotionally invested in temporary things.
- 7:00 PM: Dinner at The Surf Lodge (or, how I ate overpriced tacos and tried to look cool). The place was buzzing, the sunset was a masterpiece, and my taco nearly fell apart. I should have known better. But you know what? The air smells of romance and overpriced margaritas, I feel like I'm in a movie.
- 9:00 PM: Stumbling back to Ruschmeyer's. Feeling the sand between my toes and the slight sting of sunburn. This is what it’s like to live. To really live.
Day 2: Culture and Confusion (Or, The Day My Brain Went on Vacation Too)
- 9:00 AM: Alarm. Ugh. The joys of a good mattress. Coffee, coffee, coffee. Can't function without.
- 10:00 AM: Montauk Point Lighthouse. Beautiful. Majestic. Definitely worth the drive. (Took a wrong turn and ended up in someone's driveway again. This is becoming a theme.) The views were truly breathtaking, especially when you try and ignore all the tourists.
- 11:30 AM: Lighthouse Exploration. I actually went up the lighthouse. Turns out I'm terrified of heights. Managed to not scream hysterically, but my heart rate still hasn't recovered. And the history? Fascinating. It was like being able to see through the ages.
- 1:00 PM: Lunch at a random shack on the side of the road. Best fish tacos of my LIFE. Seriously.
- 2:30 PM: Gosman's Dock. A lively place with shops and restaurants. A sensory overload, in the best way. The lobster rolls? Killer. Found a weird but awesome souvenir, which I will definitely regret buying next week.
- 4:00 PM: The beach again. Because, well, the beach. Sat and attempted to read. Failed miserably. Just enjoying the sound of the waves.
- 7:00 PM: Dinner at Harvest on Fort Pond Bay. Decent Italian food. A little bland, to be honest. But the sunset was unreal. The way the colors hit the water. Worth it.
- 9:00 PM: Bonfire on the beach. Met some interesting characters, shared some laughs. The crackling fire, the stars… pure magic. (Someone brought marshmallows. Thank God.)
Day 3: Let's Go! (Or, My Attempt at Adventure and Embracing the Absurd)
- 9:00 AM: Breakfast: Woke up way too late.
- 10:00 AM: Surfing lesson! (Yes, it's as hilarious as it sounds). Let me tell you, I spent more time under the waves than on them. The instructor was very patient, and possibly thought I was a complete idiot. I probably am. But hey, it's the attempt that counts. Right? Right.
- 12:00 PM: Lunch: A burger and fries (and a whole lot of sand) at a beachfront diner.
- 1:30 PM: Exploring. Drove around. Found a few hidden beaches. Stopped at a farm stand for some fresh fruit. The taste of summer.
- 3:00 PM: Back to Ruschmeyer's for a nap. Exhausted. Surfing is hard work! And the sun is brutal.
- 5:00 PM: Drinks at the Salty Dog. Good drinks, great atmosphere. People-watching at its finest.
- 7:00 PM: Dinner at Inlet Seafood. More seafood! I'm practically turning into a mermaid at this point.
- 8:30 PM: Stargazing. Went stargazing, and actually, saw, a shooting star. Makes you wish for all the impossible things.
Day 4: The Bitter(sweet) End (Or, Saying Goodbye to Paradise and My Sanity)
- 9:00 AM: Breakfast: Woke up late. Again.
- 10:00 AM: Last walk on the beach. Feeling strangely sentimental. The ocean, the sun, the simple rhythm of Montauk… hard to leave it behind.
- 11:00 AM: Packing (the actual event is a disaster).
- 12:00 PM: Last lunch at… the first place I went to. Comfort food to ease the pain.
- 1:00 PM: Checking out. Saying goodbye to the lovely hotel and the memories made.
- 1:30 PM: Catching the Jitney back.
- 2:30 PM: Reflecting. I'm so glad I went. I will miss it so very much.
- 7:00 PM: Arriving home. Exhausted, sun-kissed, and possibly slightly insane. Did I remember to buy a souvenir? I am definitely going back.
And there you have it. My utterly imperfect, completely honest, and wonderfully messy Montauk adventure. It wasn't perfect, but it was mine. And that's all that matters, right? Now, if you'll excuse me, I need a nap. And maybe a therapist.
Sulphur Springs Getaway: Unbeatable Deals at Super 8 by Wyndham!
Ruschmeyer's: Montauk's Hottest? (Ugh, Let's Talk About It)
Okay, spill. Is Ruschmeyer's *really* as cool as everyone says? The Hamptons' Hotel of the Moment?
Ugh, alright, alright. It's complicated. The short answer? Yeah, it’s got some serious buzz. Like, *everyone* is there. Celebrities, influencers, the usual Montauk suspects. It’s got that whole 'rustic chic' thing down pat: the cabins, the pool, the general vibe of "I effortlessly wake up like this." But is it *cool* cool? Hmmm... Let's just say it's a mixed bag. One minute you're feeling totally bohemian, the next you're battling for a decent spot in the sun while listening to some trust fund kid complain about the lobster bisque. See, I'm getting ahead of myself. Let's break it down.
The Cabins: Are they actually cute or just tiny overpriced boxes?
Okay, the cabins. This is where the *real* drama lives. They're undeniably charming at first glance. You know, exposed wood, cozy blankets, the smell of cedar... until you actually try to *live* in one. My friend Sarah called it our *glamorous* camping trip. The first night, we were ecstatic, Instagramming every detail. By the second, we were tripping over each other, fighting over the tiny bathroom, and desperately searching for outlets because, and this is important: outlets are a luxury. Are they cute? Yes. Are they practical for more than a weekend? Absolutely not. I swear, someone could have built a mansion for what we spent!
What’s the vibe like? Relaxed and chill, or full-on Hamptons pretension?
Oh, it’s a *mix*. The intention is relaxed and chill, right? Think surfers, artists, the whole "get away from it all" narrative. But then the Hamptons elite get involved. It’s like they bring their own oxygen tanks of pretension. You’ll be sitting by the pool, trying to zen out with a book, and suddenly a gaggle of perfectly tanned people will descend, taking over all the prime real estate, ordering ridiculously complicated cocktails, and loudly discussing their "summer internships." It's exhausting. The best part? Watching them trip and fall on the uneven gravel walkways. Seriously, Karma.
The Pool: Worth the hype? Are there enough chairs? (Important!)
The pool is... a scene. It’s beautiful, I'll give them that. Stunning turquoise water, the whole shebang. But the chairs... oh god, the chair situation. It's a war zone. You have to be up before dawn to snag a decent spot. People leave their towels on chairs all day even if they don’t use them, acting like they're staking a claim to the Atlantic Ocean. I tried the "nice" approach, asking if someone was using their chair. Got a cold stare in return. I gave up and ended up sitting on a rock with a book. That was actually quite nice now that I think about it. But still.... the chair drama is real. Bring your own folding chair, seriously.
Food & Drink: Any hidden gems or is it just overpriced avocado toast?
Okay, the food. This is another area where things get... complicated. The main restaurant is decent, but not mind-blowing. Expect typical Hamptons prices. I mean *seriously* ridiculously priced. Avocado toast? Yes, it's there. And yes, its probably overpriced. The tacos they have on the pool is really what saves them. One night, we stumbled across a taco truck parked nearby (not affiliated with Ruschmeyer's, as far as I could tell, and thank god). Best tacos I’ve ever had. Seriously. That taco truck was the highlight of my trip! (I'm still dreaming about that taco.) Point being: don't expect Michelin-star dining. Maybe sneak out for a proper meal, or get a good deal on a taco.
Montauk itself – is it more than just Ruschmeyer's? What else is worth doing?
THANK GOD, yes! Montauk itself is incredible. Ruschmeyer's, for all its flaws, is just a *part* of the Montauk experience. Go to the beach! The waves are amazing. Hike the trails at Hither Woods Preserve (the views are unreal). Visit the Montauk Point Lighthouse. Go fishing! (I didn’t, but I saw other people doing it, and they seemed to enjoy it). Seriously, Montauk is beautiful and rustic, with a lot more to offer than trendy hotels. Get out, explore, and don’t spend your whole vacation just being seen. You'll find it's a great place in itself.
Would you go back? Honestly.
Ugh... that's the million-dollar question, isn't it? Okay, here's the deal. I had some amazing moments. The taco truck. The sunsets on the beach. The overall Montauk vibe. But the price? The cabin claustrophobia? The chair drama? The pretension? It's a lot to swallow. I probably *would* go back, but only if: a) I won the lottery. b) I could bribe someone to get me a good chair at the pool. c) I could sneak the taco truck into the hotel. Honestly? I've got a love-hate relationship with Ruschmeyer's. Cool? Yeah. Worth it? Jury's still out. But that taco... *sigh* Maybe. Just maybe.
Post a Comment for "Ruschmeyer's Montauk: The Hamptons' Hottest Hotel? (You NEED to See This!)"